Wednesday, February 25, 2009

Joesph Massad and Mindblowing Lectures

Yesterday, Joesph Massad came and spoke in my Palestine class. For those of you who don't know, he is a Palestinian public intellectual and academic who has written a great deal on the Palestinian-Israeli conflict and teaches at Columbia University. He spoke for about twenty minutes and then took questions from the class. In the hour and a half he was there, he managed to make me question my entire perception of the history of Middle East, Europe, and America. He was incredibly charismatic, articulate, and a genuine genius. I'll share a few ideas with all of you that do not concern Israel. I wish I could repeat what he said with even half of his eloquence. Perhaps you will find some of his ideas as interesting as I do:

1. The Islamic empires were the only external force to occupy Europe. The perception of the Islamic world as a threat is a direct result of this. Because of this, Europe understood its own identity as separate from that of its conquerers and the Middle East was "othered" in a much more complicated way than other colonized places, such as India. 

2. Greece was part of the Middle Eastern tradition, not the European tradition. The classics we claim as the basis of Western and European culture are not, in fact, Western. This was part of the artificial "othering" I discussed above. (I already knew that most of the works were translated from ancient Greek into Arabic and then into various European vernaculars, but it is interesting to think of the tradition itself as not truly European). The whole idea of Europe as a separate from Asia was really problemitized for me. 

3. "Obama was possibly the worst thing to ever happen to Black Americans." He made this claim because now any time a Black person claims that there has been racism, Whites (including liberals) can respond "Whaddya mean? If work hard like Obama, you can overcome racism." This mirrors a lot of my skepticism about Obama, and the idea that White liberals have been patting themselves on the back for their open-mindedness for electing him. That is not to say that I don't support him or his message.

4. "There is no such thing as an objective history. History is fiction that has a claim and bearings on truth." Although this has been said many times by many people, I found his phrasing wonderful.

5. Americans will look you in the eye with a straight face and tell you that they have 200 years of democracy. But the first hundred years there was slavery and for nearly a hundred after that there were Jim Crow laws and Blacks did not have the right to vote. Women could not vote for the majority of those 200 years as well. But if someone from South Africa said "We've had democracy for 60 years," you would look at them like they were crazy.

By the end of the lecture, I pretty much came to understand that Orientialism is responsible for nearly everything I know about the world and the way I perceive it. Although this is not an entirely new realization, the depth of it is. I've been thinking about his remarks quite a bit. I hope you also find them interesting!

Lots of Love,
MJS


Sunday, February 22, 2009

Bombs and Whatnot




As I'm sure many of you have heard, there was a bomb that went of in Khan el-Khalili today. It is THE open air market in Cairo and a huge tourist destination. I went a few weeks ago and had a very lovely time. There is nothing definite yet about how many people have been killed or injured, but my friends and I are fine. One person I know was roughly thirty meters from the cafe when the bomb went off, but being a Palestinian from Bethlehem, he did not seem too impressed. His reaction? "It was just a bomb." I think all of the Americans I was with in the dorms when it happened were way more freaked out than him. 
www.google.com/hostednews/ap/article/ALeqM5h5hCnSXpjKsUh778941rnW-PgeawD96GSJM01

Perhaps what was more shocking to me was that the Egyptian government took an AUC grad student who was leading a protest about Gaza a few weeks ago and held him for a week without releasing any information. You might have read about it in the New York Times. Shortly after the international press got the information, he was released. His dual Egyptian-German citizenship probably also helped his situation. It is THIS kind of activity that makes Egypt a dangerous place to live more than any bombings, at least for its citizens. Perhaps we can be hopeful for the future. Just last week the government released Ayman Nour, the opposition leader, after more than three years in prison for "forgery". I am optimistic about the effectf of Obama's presidency in this part of the world (to the exclusion of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict). 
www.cnn.com/2009/WORLD/meast/02/18/egypt.release/index.html

After having been here for one month, I can finally say that things here are slowly but surely improving. I'm starting to feel more comfortable around the city, especially in Zamalek (the island on which I'm living). Although I still feel uncomfortable at times, I am more confident in my ability to get around and in handling unwanted attention. I have come to accept that I will inevitably be an outsider and hardly distinguishable from a tourist for the duration of my stay. It has been a hard thing to realize, but I am hoping to learn as much as I can with that in mind. I've decided to drop one of my classes at AUC and use the extra time to start volunteering teaching English to refugees. I'll let you know how that goes once it's all straightened out. I think it will be a better and more fulfilling use of my time.

I miss all of you very much.
Love Love,
MJS

P.S. I've added some photos, as promised. Sorry I've been sort of lazy about that. I will try to put up some more soon.

Tuesday, February 17, 2009

A Cultural Note

Those who live in Cairo describe the way the city functions as "organized chaos." To those of us who are just visitors, it appears to be mostly just chaos plain and simple. For example, people don't acknowledge lines here. If you are standing less than 6 inches away from the person in front of you, you are likely to get cut in line. The person behind you will most likely be touching you in some way (did I mention personal space is also not a concept here?) Another example of this city's chaos is that there is no such thing as a traffic lane here. Cars push between if there is even the slightest bit of space. A bridge with two lanes is likely to have four cars abreast. Traffic signs and lights are routinely ignored. A traffic officer has to accompany them if cars are going to obey, and even this is not a guarantee- my cab driver this weekend simply waved off a cop trying to tell him to stop and proceeded to drive into an intersection with cars driving every which way. It was quite an adventure. Everything has endless people involved. For example, to print something at the AUC library, you do not simply swipe a card at the printer, but rather you go into a little room with not one but two people to take your money and hand you your printed paper. Anything to create a job!
We Americans deal with this by imitating to greeting shouted at us from passing cars and street corners: "Welcome to EEEEEgypt!" This is our anthem whenever things go awry- when it takes hours to do a simple task or when someone leans on a table and watches it break. However, there are a few local sayings to describe the Egyptian mentality about the disorder.
First, there is Ma3lesh/Mahlesh
This roughly translates to "Whatever!" People say this all the time to remain sane. If something doesn't go right, they simply shrug and respond "ma3lesh".
Secondly, Insha'allah
This literally translates "God Willing" but actually means one of two things: "Hopefully" or "Hopefully, but probably not. Come back tomorrow. We'll see." People say this to dispel their responsibility- it is not in their hands, if God wants it to happen then it will.
It is only with these two mentalities that one can hope to remain sane in Cairo. I am trying to learn this kind of patience. I think I am starting to get there, in spite of my nature as an efficiency freak and general impatience. I keep repeating the mantra "mahlesh, mahlesh, mahlesh", hoping it will stick. So we'll see how that works out... Things will improve, insha'allah.
I miss you all so much! I hope that everything is going well. I am dying for some Oberlin news. I'm going to try to post more often here now that I'm getting used to a routine.
Many hugs and warm thoughts,
M

Saturday, February 7, 2009

oh cairo

So, those of you who have been in touch with me know that I've been having a pretty rough time here. The pollution has been giving me really terrible headaches. On top of all of the problems with the school's bureaucracy and the culture shock (harassment, etc), it was all too much and I was seriously considering coming home, but have decided to stay. I knew when I decided to come here that it wasn't going to be easy, I just didn't realize how hard it was going to be.
The new campus where classes are held is an hour to an hour and a half shuttle ride from the dorms. It is in New Cairo, which is a city that is being built all at once. There are almost no completed structures there, just miles of development in every direction. It seems to be a place for the rich elite of Cairo to flee the city and all of its problems. We call the new campus Disney World because it is this huge, opulent (arguably beautiful) place that is totally clean and artificial feeling- you look out and just see desert or development. Construction on the school is still underway, and it is all very disorganized. Getting anything done takes ages. The bureaucracy  is enough to make you tear your hair out- just getting a school ID card took me 2 hours. Efficiency is a concept lost upon the Egyptians altogether it seems- something that never ceases to frustrate me.
In Egypt, public university is nearly free, but what you can study is restricted based on how well you score on an exam after high school (much like the system in many European countries). The American University in Cairo is very expensive in comparison. The students there a largely very wealthy and not committed to their studies. I have often joked that Oberlin is a costume party, but AUC is a fashion show. I have never seen wealth flaunted in the way the students do here- the standard for girls is a giant Gucci/Vuitton monogram bag and huge Chanel sunglasses, while boys wear euro-trash standards such as overwashed diesel jeans and velcro lacotse shoes and big aviator sunglasses. It has made me realize another, deeper reason for the anti-western sentiment in the Middle East- aside from tourism and the media, the average Egyptian encounters the West through the wealthy Egyptians' flashy adoption of western material culture. With such rampant poverty, it is easy to understand the distain of that culture.
I finally got my classes worked out after going to the registration office every day for a week. I'm going to be taking Introduction to Islamic Art and Architecture, Islamic Architecture of Egypt and Syria (with a focus on the Mamluk period), Modern Movements in Islam, Islamist Movements from Militancy to Power Sharing (which looks awesome- one of the texts is "Al-Qaeda in its Own Qords"), and Palestine: A Novel Approach, which is co-taught by a political science professor and a comparative literature professor, with both literary and scholarly writings used to examine the conflict. I think it is going to be a solid schedule, and I have a three day weekend. I plan on getting an Arabic tutor to work with me on colloquial Arabic rather than taking classes at AUC. There wasn't a colloquial class to really suit my level, and this way I'll be learning useful things rather than how to say "united nations" (as in my Modern Standard Arabic class in Oberlin).
Today, I went with 7 Egyptians and 5 other Americans to Ain El Sokhna, which is about two hours outside of Cairo and right on the Red Sea. Our friend Hezam has a beach house there and we lounged around, played volleyball, and went swimming in incredibly clear water. The weather was great (80 degrees) and the beach was really beautiful. Things are definitely looking up.
I miss you all very much! Give me some updates on how everything is going. If you do send me mail, you must also put my room number in the address (I corrected it in the post below). I'll try to post again soon.
Lots of love,
M